Olivia Earls went to Kroger for flowers. Then she spotted Fiona’s favorite treat and knew what to bring to the zoo.
LUTHMANN NOTE: Before I put somebody’s name in a story, I want to know what the reader learns by seeing it. Take Olivia Earls. She told a local reporter why she brought a watermelon, and anybody who’s ever carried dinner to a grieving neighbor understood her. Now give me one good reason to print the kid’s name. The zoo knows where the hat got in. A reporter can ask whether that opening needs closing without putting a child’s face on a stranger’s screen. If you want a name worth passing around this Christmas, you’ve got one. Give the ink to Olivia. This piece is “She Brought a Watermelon.”
By Matt “Sully” Sullivan and Zoey Lynne Zvezda with Richard Luthmann
CINCINNATI, OHIO – Olivia Earls went to Kroger to buy flowers for a dead hippo. Then she saw the watermelon. She put it this way to WCPO’s Jay Shakur: “What do you do for a family when they lose somebody? You know, you bring them a casserole.” Fiona liked watermelon. So that’s what Earls brought to the Cincinnati Zoo.
I’d give that woman a column before I’d give another minute of airtime to anybody paid to explain what’s wrong with America. She saw something in the produce aisle that reminded her of somebody she’d miss. Most of us know exactly what she meant by the casserole.

Fiona was nine. On November 8, a child tossed a knit hat into the air inside the zoo’s viewing area. According to the zoo’s account of the accident, a ceiling fan caught the hat and sent it through a narrow opening into the enclosure. Fiona swallowed it. On November 19, the zoo announced she had died.
For eleven days, the keepers and veterinarians tried to get that hat through her. They gave her IV fluids. They borrowed a vibration table from a horse farm. They tried a nine-foot scope. If you’re wondering why nobody could just reach in and pull the damn thing out, the postmortem answered that question. The hat had lodged in her small intestine, 25 feet past the last compartment of her stomach and about 50 feet from the other end. Nine feet was never going to get there.

It’s easier to understand what those eleven days cost the people at that zoo if you know what they went through to get Fiona her first month. On January 24, 2017, her mother, Bibi, gave birth six weeks early. Fiona weighed 29 pounds. She couldn’t stand long enough to nurse. By February, she was dehydrated, and the people who knew hippos needed help from people who knew something about getting a needle into a very small vein.

Two members of the vascular access team at Cincinnati Children’s came over with an ultrasound machine. The first IV lasted half an hour. The vein gave out. They found a deeper one in her leg. Five bags of fluid later, Fiona was taking a bottle again. The zoo remembered the favor. Babies in the hospital’s newborn intensive care unit got little outfits with Fiona on them. Imagine being a parent at that bedside and learning why there was a hippo on your kid’s onesie.

People got nine years with Fiona because somebody knew whom to call and somebody else came. She got big enough to swim with her parents. She became a big sister to Fritz. Cincinnati even let her pick a Super Bowl winner. She picked the hometown Bengals. In the interest of full disclosure, the zoo admitted the Bengals toy was bigger and had more treats around it.

After she died, six-year-old Bristol Makin of Cheviot brought a handwritten goodbye. She drew a heart on it because she loved Fiona. Second Lady Usha Vance shared a picture of one of her children face-to-face with Fiona through the glass. Chelsea Clinton dug out her pictures, too. Try getting those two families into the same political ad. Yet here they were, doing what families do when they hear the news: looking for that one good picture.

That doesn’t tell me how Ohio will vote. It tells me something I find more useful in America’s 250th year. We can disagree about who ought to run the country and still recognize a loss in somebody else’s house. A little girl with a crayon doesn’t need instruction in that. Some of the adults could use a refresher.
Strangers online had a different response. Some were demanding that the child who tossed the hat be identified and prosecuted. The zoo described an accident. A child threw a hat in the air. A fan put it somewhere nobody expected. There’s a fair question about closing that opening. Dragging a kid’s name onto the internet won’t close it. And if you’ve got room in your heart for a hippopotamus but none for a child who made a mistake, what exactly are you defending?

Christmas is coming. For those of us who believe in God, the Catechism puts our obligation to animals in five words: “Thus men owe them kindness.” The keepers in Cincinnati put in eleven days trying. We can spare a prayer for them. We can spare one for that kid. And if there’s somebody you owe a visit, take the apple pie over while there’s still somebody home to answer the door.

One last thing about Olivia Earls. She could have bought the flowers. Nobody would have thought twice. But she remembered what Fiona liked, and even after the animal was gone, that detail still mattered to her. The next time somebody tells you Americans don’t know how to care about one another anymore, tell them about the woman who brought the watermelon.
Related posts:

STATEN ISLAND GOES SOVIET: DA WANTS FLORIDA JOURNALIST EXTRADITED FOR REPORTING AND FACEBOOK SATIRE

CTE and Chris Simon: The Unicorn of Hockey’s Warrior Era

Bombadiko’s Boys Have Arrived! ROAR!

PRISONERS’ RABBI DIES AT 78

CharityWatch Loses Tax-Free Collar?







Leave a Reply